The puzzle of writing: Comparing jigsaw puzzles and dissertations

When embarking on the journey of writing a dissertation, one might find surprising parallels to the seemingly unrelated task of completing a complex jigsaw puzzle. Both activities require skill, patience, strategy, and a keen eye for detail. However, they also present unique challenges and rewards. I this post I will explore some of the key differences and similarities between these two challenging endeavours.

Differences

🧩Known vs. Unknown outcome A jigsaw puzzle starts with a clear picture on the box, guiding you towards the final image. Each piece has a predetermined place, and the challenge lies in fitting them together. In contrast, a dissertation begins with a question or hypothesis, and the outcome is often unknown. The research process can lead to unexpected findings, and the final product may differ significantly from any initial vision.

🧩 Fixed vs. Variable pieces Jigsaw puzzles come with a fixed number of pieces, each uniquely shaped to fit into the overall picture. The pieces are known from the start, and their shapes do not change. Writing a dissertation involves gathering information from various sources, and the "pieces" of your research can vary in number and form. New data may emerge, requiring adjustments to your original plan.

🧩 Time to completion Completing a jigsaw puzzle can take days to weeks, depending on its complexity. Writing a dissertation, however, is a much longer process, often spanning months to years. The extended timeline requires sustained effort and dedication, making it a marathon rather than a sprint.

Similarities

🧩 Longer than expected Both jigsaw puzzles and dissertations take longer to complete than initially anticipated. The process of fitting pieces together or conducting thorough research can reveal unforeseen challenges, requiring additional time and effort.

🧩 Tools to assist Just as puzzle enthusiasts use cases, frames, and roll-up mats to organise their pieces, dissertation writers rely on databases, methodology books, and guidance from tutors. These tools and resources are essential for managing the complexity of the task and ensuring progress.

🧩 Multiple touchpoints Neither a jigsaw puzzle nor a dissertation can be completed in one go. Both require breaking the task into manageable sections and tackling them one at a time. Sorting puzzle pieces by colour and pattern or dividing research into chapters and subtopics helps maintain focus and momentum.

🧩 Taking breaks When frustration sets in, taking a break is crucial. Puzzle enthusiasts know that stepping away from the puzzle can provide a fresh perspective and renewed energy. Similarly, dissertation writers benefit from breaks to clear their minds and return to their work with a fresh outlook. Whether it's drinking tea or going for a walk, these moments of rest are vital for maintaining productivity and creativity.

Approaching a dissertation as if it were a difficult jigsaw puzzle can offer several benefits for dissertation students. Here are some key advantages: 

💡Enhanced organisation and structure Just as puzzle enthusiasts sort pieces by colour and pattern, dissertation students can break their work into manageable sections, while needing to consider the whole of the puzzle / dissertation. Dividing research into chapters and subtopics helps maintain focus and momentum, making the task less overwhelming.

💡Increased patience and perseverance Everyone knows that completing a complex jigsaw puzzle often takes longer than expected. Approaching a dissertation like a difficult jigsaw puzzle teaches students to accept that answers won't be immediate, fostering the development of  patience and perseverance skills. By seeing the dissertation as a complex puzzle, students learn to stay committed to their research, even when faced with uncertainty, challenges or setbacks.

💡Managing Expectations Understanding that, like a jigsaw puzzle, a dissertation will take longer to complete than initially anticipated helps students manage their expectations and accept such reality, staying motivated throughout the process.

💡Enjoyment of the process The prospect of working on a project that will take many months (if not years) to complete with uncertain result can be daunting. Seeing a dissertation as a fairly complex jigsaw puzzle can make the writing process more enjoyable. Students can appreciate the challenge and satisfaction of fitting each piece together, ultimately leading to a sense of accomplishment when the final product is complete.

* * *

In conclusion, while doing a complex jigsaw puzzle and writing a dissertation may seem worlds apart, they share common threads such as strategy, purpose, and perseverance. Seeing a dissertation as a fairly complex jigsaw puzzle can help dissertation students develop skills, strategies and mindsets that will aid them in their dissertation journey and beyond.

If you want help with developing effective dissertation skills, strategies and mindset, consider getting hold of the Virtual Tutor Resource, which contains over 13 hours of videos explaining how to write a top dissertation. And if you feel you would benefit from direct input from an experienced supervisor to help you write a top dissertation, consider getting my support.